Distressed in Destitution
David Tam
Eng 101
Professor Matyukubova
12/13/19
Abstract
This research paper emphasizes about how people are being treated unfairly in society due to poverty in the United States. Poverty is setting people up for failure and the government is putting these people down. Research has shown that many people in poverty are being discriminated against because of social class, ethnicity, appearance, and in prison. Many people in the criminal justice system is purposely targeting these individuals to prevent them from succeeding. This research paper will bring many sources ranging from peer professional articles, government articles, Yale journal review articles, interview, newspaper, literature, and podcast. Furthermore, there will be charts illustrating the statistics about how much of a disadvantage it is for people in poverty. Throughout the research there will be issues starting from childhood leading up to incarceration and life after prison. The research paper will provide solutions to prevent poverty and make the United States more prosperous. The whole point of this research paper is to make people understand the difficulties that people in poverty have to face every day.
Distressed in Destitution
There is a huge epidemic with the United States bureaucratic punishment system. People in society who are struggling financially believe in the American dream. Sadly the majority of these people will not fulfill their dreams and this is because they are in poverty. Poverty is defined as not living comfortably financially or in the state of being inferior in quality. Moreover, the population in the United States in 2018 was 327.2 million people according to the Census Bureau. The Census Bureau also states that there are 40 million people and rising who are in poverty. The United States brands itself as the greatest country on Earth but there are many homeless people who are being treated unfairly and are lacking the necessities in life. The government is supposed to help and provide services to aid poor people but there is sufficient evidence that the government is doing the opposite. There are ways that poverty relates to crime, discrimination, lack of education, lack of parenting, and incarceration. In addition, poverty is setting people up for failure in the United States.

Poverty starts from the beginning as a child. Like George Orwell once said “poverty annihilates the future.” Children who are poor are less educated and are malnourished. This sets children at a disadvantage for the future and the child has not even made any decisions for itself. This chart from the article “The Importance of Early Childhood Poverty” by Greg J. Duncan shows a wealth class of kindergarteners learning capabilities and 19% of children that are poor recognize letters unlike children in the middle class 72% of them recognize letters. Children who live in poverty would be dangerous for their future because living in poverty is stressful for the parents. The parents are not providing higher quality education, nutritious foods, living in a peaceful neighborhood, and most importantly teaching their child. Parental guidance could be improved for people in poverty. For example, the article states “research has proven that low-income parents are more likely to use an authoritarian parenting style and less likely to provide their children with stimulating learning experiences in the home.” (Duncan, 2011 Part 3). Authoritarian parenting is not beneficial for children because parents punish their child very severely for mistakes and the child does not comprehend what they did wrong. Poverty is a continuous cycle and it is very difficult for people to succeed because people do not understand the problem. The article states that “children from poor families also go on to complete less schooling, work less, and earn less.” (Duncan, 2011 Part 1). This is because these families cannot afford the schooling and they have little to no experience applying for jobs. A solution is to increase welfare like food stamps so the family would not have to worry about when their next meal is going to be. Moreover, having more welfare in general would make families less stress about financial stability. As children are growing up they will experience how people in the lower class is being mistreated. In addition, homeless people are being discriminated against and they cannot defend themselves.
There are real life examples of how corrupt and unfair life is for homeless people. For example, the book “The Divide: American Injustice in the Age of the Wealth Gap” by Matt Taibbi in Chapter 2 the book explains that a man named Tory Marone became homeless in New York City and he was stopped and frisked with no probable cause. The reasoning for Tory Marone to be stopped and frisked by a police officer was because “he looked like he was up to no good.” (Taibbi, 2014 Chapter 2). Unfortunately for Marone the police found half a joint of weed in his pocket and the bail was set $1,000 dollars for the possession of marijuana. This is a very corrupt way for the punishment system to make money because he cannot afford to pay for bail and half a joint of marijuana is not worth near $1,000 dollars. Moreover, Tory Marone had to serve 40 days in Rikers Island because he could not pay the excessive fine. This violates the 8th Amendment of having excessive punishment but police officers would do anything to look for crime to reach their arrest quota. In addition, the punishment system would be losing money because they would have to pay for him to be in prison such as housing, food, and clothes. On the other hand, the book later explains that a bank known as HSBC was “permitting narcotic trafficking and money laundering up to hundreds of millions of dollars.” (Taibbi, 2014 Chapter 2). Furthermore, Lanny Breuer, the head of the Criminal Division of the Justice Department announces his punishment for the bank of HSBC which was a big fine of $1.9 billion dollars. There was no terms of jail time, no real penalty, and no individual being charged for what they have done. The only penalty was a settlement. This is unfair because a homeless man cannot afford the fine and obviously a corporate bank can afford the penalty so the punishment was basically a slap on the wrist. Moreover, it shows the disparity between the lower class people and how corrupt organizations could not be accountable for their actions. To resolve some issues New York City has fixed the law with marijuana making it a misdemeanor and the fine could only be up to $250. In addition, in 2020 New York City is limiting bail because the criminal justice system realizes many people cannot afford bail. But, this is not stopping police officers from being immoral.
In The New York Times article titled “Is it now a Crime to be Poor” by Ehrenreich Barbara the article is about how police officers are focusing on misdemeanor crimes such as ticketing people for jaywalking, littering, avoiding the MTA fare, and carrying an open container of alcohol. This is a corrupt way of police officers making their arrest quota because even though it is their job many homeless people do not have any income to pay for these fines. The worst part about it is police officers would go through homeless shelters in the middle of the night to see if anyone has an outstanding warrant to arrest them. There was a case that police officers arrested a man named Al Szekely for criminal trespassing and was dragged out of the shelter to be put in jail. The criminal justice system is supposed to rehabilitate people but it seems like they are just punishing people. How is society supposed to be better if the criminal justice system does not change? The article proposes solutions such as “drug offenders going to rehabilitation centers, shortening probation, and reduce misdemeanor crimes.” (Barbara 2009 last paragraph). Furthermore, to avoid homelessness the government should implement affordable housing, well-funded education systems, reliable public transportation, and better trained police officers. Many people would argue that police officers are corrupt due to social media but there are reliable police officers that want justice.
Throughout my research I interviewed an expert on my topic asking their opinions on poverty. I interviewed David Sarni, a Criminal Justice Professor at John Jay of Criminal Justice. David Sarni was a detective for 22 years before he started teaching. Professor Sarni agrees that poverty is an issue that involves people to commit crimes and they happen to be minorities. For example, he says that in the 2018 Uniform Crime Report it showed that minorities commit more homicides. Moreover, from his experience he notices that more juveniles are committing crimes in areas such as the Bronx and Queens. His solutions to resolve crimes is for more community involvement, more after school activities, more parental involvement, police officers to be retrained, and community outreach programs. Even though these solutions are not that easy to be implemented it can happen if communities believe this is a major issue and want to end poverty. But right now there are many crimes that are associated with poverty.
In the article “Income inequality, poverty and crime across nations” by Paul-Philippe Pare this article focuses on the relationship between income inequality, poverty, and different types of crime. In addition, they explain that they have found a positive association between income inequality and homicide rates. The article states “poor people may be more likely to commit crime because their opportunities are blocked and because they are exposed to a wide variety of negative experiences.” (Pare, 2014 Paragraph 3). This is true because in poor neighborhoods they are lacking the funding in the education system. For example, it states “inequality in resources implies that there are great riches within view but not within reach of many people destined to live in poverty.” (Pare, 2014 Paragraph 8). Many children that have potential of being successful are being held back due to social class and the lack of resources. In addition, it states “that poor people may engage in violent crime to handle their grievances because they lack access to the legal system.” (Pare, 2014 Paragraph 4). Not only poor people but everyone in general relate their experiences with people around them and this can be negative experiences. For example, some people are associated with crime because people in society experience the pain of frustration. These people are lacking the control to succeed just because of their environment and the people around them. Like Aristotle once said “show me your friends and I will show you your future.” People are who they associate themselves with and if they associate with other people who are criminals they will commit crimes. This is how teenagers are recruited to gangs because they can relate to their upbringings. In addition, this is how crimes happen because of a lack of guardianship.
In the government article titled “Urban Poverty and Neighborhood Effects on Crime: Incorporating Spatial and Network Perspectives” by Corina Graif, Andrew GladFelter, and Stephen A. Matthews. They first start by explaining classic ecological studies showed that neighborhoods with high poverty near commercial and industrial districts exhibited the highest level of delinquency and criminality from the introduction. The reasoning for this is because in many of these districts since there is a high number of commuters between two neighborhoods it would be more difficult to control crime. Since there is a lack of crime control there could be more gang presence which would influence adolescents. Furthermore, they explain that the time period plays a huge role because the Great Recession of 2008 put greater pressure to low income urban families which connects to higher crime. For example they stated families are at a “risk of victimization, aggression, domestic violence, incarceration, and exposure to violence.” (Graif, 2014 Paragraph 4). They explain crimes happen because the lack of guardianship, unemployment, and how peers may influence offending behavior. These are many of the reasons why teenagers are involved with criminal activity. For example, the Great Recession had many people unemployed so the article stated “time spent out of the household would lead to low level of guardianship” (Graif, 2014 Paragraph 6). These are factors that cannot be controlled by an individual and they are being punished just because the economy is in a deficit. Moreover, there were factors such as the war on drugs were targeting poor minorities.
In the article “Par for the course? Exploring the impacts of incarceration and marginalization on poor black men in the U.S” by Nekima Levy-Pounds states that there is an “increased rate of violence, drug related crime, crack-cocaine distribution, and the war surged because of poor inner city communities.” (Pounds, 2013 Paragraph 2). The article explains that there is a strong disparity because despite evidence that African Americans and white individuals use drugs at roughly even rates the media portrays African Americans heavily involved in drug related crimes. Furthermore, since African Americans have a lower level of education, this increases the involvement in survival crimes such as low level drug trafficking. The system is putting them down because of historical racial discrimination and inequities which hinders their success in the labor force. For example, to limit poor African Americans during the 1880s there were Jim Crow Laws that stated “separate but equal laws” but this was a huge disparity because the schooling systems were not funded equally on purpose. The government wanted to limit African Americans and keep them poor because having uneducated people would benefit the government. The reasoning for this is the more uneducated people the less likely people would notice the disparity and the issues. But, more recently there has been a huge disparity in the war on drugs and this is leading to slavery again.

In a Yale Law Journal article “The Punishment Bureaucracy: How to Think About “Criminal Justice Reform” by Alec Karakatsanis the article has statistics of how poor African Americans are being mistreated and that the criminal justice reform is broken. This chart shows that the racial and ethnic gaps are shrinking for the inmate population but African Americans are still the highest incarnation. Moreover, the article states “There are 2.2 million human beings incarcerated in the United States and another 4.5 million people are under government control through probation and parole supervision.” (Karakatsanis 2019 Part 2). The United States has five percent of the world’s population, yet the United States alone has twenty-five percent of the world’s prisoners and the highest rate of incarceration. Furthermore, between eighty and ninety percent of the people charged with crimes are so poor that they cannot afford a lawyer. There is also a strong disparity with minorities who are in poverty. For example, the article states that “federal law treats cocaine offenses more harshly than most drugs.” (Karakatsanis 2019). But, there is a strong biased between crack cocaine and powdered cocaine. Even though these two drugs are nearly identical the law arrest more people with crack cocaine. This is because poor African Americans possess more crack cocaine and not a single white person who had possession of powdered cocaine was arrested in the seven biggest cities in the United States in decades. In addition, there was a disparity of the 100:1 crack cocaine ratio meaning that possession of 1 gram of crack cocaine would be the same minimum sentence as 100 grams of powder cocaine. Crack cocaine is a federal crime but the criminal justice system is purposely targeting poor African Americans. Moreover, African American people in Alabama are being mistreated because the state passed a law to take away the right to vote for the possession of crack cocaine. The article states “the purpose of this law was to reduce the amount of black people from voting.” (Karakatsanis 2019 Part 5B). The government is purposely discriminating against minorities and people in poverty. These poor people are being treated unfairly and everyone understands drugs can lead to incarceration but sometimes they do not have a choice. Furthermore, being incarcerated is another form of slavery.
In the podcast called the “Appeal Episode 53: A Lack of Basic Rights for Incarcerated Workers” it speaks about how incarcerated workers do not have any rights. They mention that they are basically slaves and it is very insidious. Moreover, there is no economic appeal in this. The podcast states "many states pay incarcerated workers just 20 or 30 cents per hour and some don't pay them at all." They mention a man named Kendall Charles Xavier who was an African American engineer. But, they mention him when he was in prison he was a sewing mechanic and made 20 cents per hour. They promised him compensation to make more money but the wage did not increase until 7 months later. He states he was being “discriminated against about how he was not getting the same benefits because of his skin color.” They treat inmates like they are not people and life after prison is even worse. For example, there are three exclusions for people coming out of prison back to civilian life. The first exclusion is about how difficult for ex-convicts to find jobs. They are limited with their education because the government is not willing to give federal aid. The second exclusion is about the lack of government assistance such as welfare, food stamps, Medicaid, and any other benefits. Moreover, the final exclusion is how they are not allowed to participate in voting. Many of them would go back to crime because the country turned its back on the people living in it. Prison is supposed to rehabilitate inmates but it seems like they will always be punished for the rest of their lives and there is no retribution.
In conclusion, poverty is a terrible state to be in but there are solutions to help people in need. Some solutions are more funding for schools for after school activities like LeBron James said “basketball kept him off the streets and helped him stay focused on what was important.” There should be more parental involvement and more community outreach programs. Having a strong community is essential because people actually care about where they live and want to limit the possibility of crime. Moreover, having a Universal Income would be beneficial. This is Andrew Yang’s president’s campaign for 2020 and this is about guaranteeing people in poverty money. An example of this is Alaska the state deposits at least 25 percent of mineral royalties’ revenue the state generates from its oil and gas reserves into the fund annually. Each resident receives $2,000 every year. Universal Income could happen by having an added value tax which is a goods and services tax. Basically taxing major corporations such as Amazon, Google, and Facebook they will get taxed on every sale and that money will get redistributed to the poor population. This is a very efficient because the middle class should not pay the most taxes because the rich has the most income out of everyone. Everyone in the United States can make a difference and people should recognize these issues. All and all, like Nelson Mandala once said “poverty is not an accident. Like slavery and apartheid, it is manmade and can be removed by the actions of human beings.”
References
D Sarni, F. Interview (2019) “Distressed in Destitution” by David Tam
Duncan, G. J., & Magnuson, K. (2013). The importance of poverty early in childhood. Policy Quarterly, 9(2). doi: 10.26686/pq.v9i2.4448
Ehrenreich, B. (2009, August 9). Is it Now a Crime to be Poor? Retrieved from
https://search-proquest-com.ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/usmajordailies/docview/434167709/fulltext/63F7F9C572BD43C9PQ/2?accountid=11724.
Felson , R. (2014, September 23). Income inequality, poverty and crime across nations. Retrieved from
https://onlinelibrary-wiley-com.ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/doi/full/10.1111/1468-4446.12083.
Levy-Pounds, N. (2013, December 22). Par for the course? Exploring the impacts of incarceration and marginalization on poor black men in the U.S. . Retrieved from https://go-gale-com.ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/ps/i.do?ty=as&v=2.1&u=cuny_johnjay&it=DIourl&s=RELEVANCE&p=LT&qt=SN~1538-5876~~TI~"VULNERABLE POPULATION PAR FOR"~~VO~14~~SP~29&lm=DA~120130000&sw=w.
Matthews , S. A. (2014, September 8). Urban Poverty and Neighborhood Effects on Crime: Incorporating Spatial and Network Perspectives. Retrieved from
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4928692/.
Taibbi, M. (2014). The divide: American injustice in the age of the wealth gap. New York: Spiegel & Grau.
The Appeal Episode 53: A Lack of Basic rights for Incarcerated Workers (2019, October 24) Retrieved from
https://theappealpodcast.libsyn.com/episode-53-a-lack-of-basic-rights-for-incarcerated-workers
The Punishment Bureaucracy: How to Think About "Criminal Justice Reform". (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.yalelawjournal.org/forum/the-punishment-bureaucrac